Excerpts from the introduction to this course: |
|
Dear Teacher, This package and its sequenced readings are the product of thirty years’ experience teaching an articulated and aligned curriculum in high performance public schools. Its contents have been tested with over 5000 students, each of whom has come to delight in coursework that is rooted in essential concepts to which they return again and again as they journey forward to acquire new skills and apply new learning. This is a truly articulated curriculum. Each learning activity builds upon the one that preceded it, and prepares the way for the next that is to come. The familiar neighborhood of inquiry established by this approach answers two challenging questions that can often trouble students. The first is: “why are we doing this?” The second is: “what does this have to do with me, and/or with our class activities”? A thematic curriculum that centers upon universally important human and cultural questions—rather than one organized by chronology or by nationality of author—is best positioned to answer questions like these. What is more interesting to each of our students than the narrative of his/her own personal history and challenges? Individual lives share fundamental similarities: each person begins as an infant, and as adolescence approaches, temporarily separates from parents (as did Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz) to explore the world and find his/her own true path. No one is exempt: each of us journeys from childhood to adulthood, and each of us experiences the trade-offs, the advantages and the nostalgic regrets, that such a transition invokes. This is called ontogeny. But the ontogenetic journey is a microcosm of a much larger, historical transformation: As a species, we all share the mixed blessings of the neolithic revolution effected some fifteen thousand years ago. This was the time when our nomadic, wild-game following ancestors discovered agriculture and learned the secrets of animal domestication. No more following herds: now it was more profitable to plant a food crop and stay in one place. As a result, our forebears were forced into a steep learning curve of technological and social advancement: they invented architecture for dwellings and food storage, they invented cuneiform writing as a means of recording trade transactions, and they created all the familiar structures of the modern world: cities, armies and written laws to protect property and manage relations between larger groups of human beings who, having given up the hunt, now lived in one permanent location at close proximity--but who were no longer related to each other as in the old tribal or kinship days. New York, Cairo, Sao Paolo, Beijing, traffic congestion, multi-nationals, war: these are all products of--and footnotes to--what anthropologists call phylogeny. These journeys--both ontogenetic and phylogenetic--concern human beings immediately and directly. They are central to our questioning of ourselves, our roles, and our relationship to the larger world that, intact, insistent and powerfully established, receives us at our birth. Themes like these concern youth and elderly alike. They focus our attention, speak to our personal experience, and when they are incorporated into the classroom, themes like these release us from an all too common, prophylactic, thought stifling instructional format: the dryness of literary anthologies that group works and ideas into national, curatorial or culture specific compartments that are walled-off from universal concerns. Secondary students are not interested in specialized literary debates; are not interested in tracing the origins of this or that poem to some local, social or political concern of the eighteenth century. The students that we teach need big pictures, not narrowly focused graduate school specificity that serves professorial or thesis writer dead-ends. They need an introduction to universal ideas; they need to learn to read patterns between works that span cultures and epochs; and they need opportunities to discover the personal significance of the questions that humans have always been concerned with. Our goal at the secondary level should be to equip students to engage in meaningful and personally relevant activities: •Thoughtful reflection about history and progress •Thoughtful reflection about the trade-offs between personal desires and social obligations •The ability to read carefully and to make intelligent, evidentiary connections between apparently diverse narratives •And the ability to confidently answer big picture questions such as: “how does literature present us with an image of the forces and events that shape our lives? And how does it achieve it respective ends?" The simple answer to this latter question is: literature is the medium through which thoughtful writers attempt to interpret and attain some measure of understanding--and hopefully, control--over our ontogenetic and phylogenetic histories. Before written language, these efforts were the impetus behind the sympathetic magic of the cave paintings such as we see at Altamira. After written language, these same efforts were undertaken by a new class of artists: writers, who gave us the Epic of Gilgamesh, Beowulf, Hamlet and The Scarlet Letter, to name a few. In this thematic curriculum, questions such as "what is literature concerned with" can be continuously applied to any work that might be read; and students find themselves at the center as they mull the similarities and differences between works that explore the same big ideas. The center of this literature course is about extracting meaning; about interpretation; about using the comparative mode to read carefully; and about coming to understand the ways that all stories converge around—and reinterpret—universal themes. An approach like this is what makes the journey through this course both meaningful and purposive for students. What is Contained In This Program & Its Duration I have assembled nineteen texts and commentaries for you to use in a sequence, although you may supplement with your own favorite material all along the way. But the sequence presented here is important and should be adhered to. This is because work #1 prepares the way for work #2 and so on. This is what curricular articulation insists upon. The short texts I have selected are of high interest. I have used each successfully with students ranging from grades 7 to grade 12. The texts are simple, but they can be daunting in terms of the interpretive challenges they impose. This is not a course on "Red Badge of Courage" or "The Great Gatsby." Instead, it is a course that uses carefully selected short pieces that enables student to establish an interpretive framework that they can successfully use to read these and other important literary works. The curriculum is designed to challenge all levels of students—easy enough to tie into for the less literarily inclined, and rich and deep enough to fully engage curriculum weary juniors and seniors who already have their sights set on enrolling in a high quality university. This material is especially suitable for AP classes—including the simple story “Sylvester and the Magic Pebble,” which is an illustrated children’s book running to around twenty or thirty pages of drawings. Put within the context of the thematic architecture of the course, this story is highly challenging. If this “simple” work is approached in the true spirit of the course design, it will work every time. What’s more, it will provide important information that students need as they advance to the next work. Hence, I request that you not determine on your own that this or that work is suitable or not suitable in terms of level of difficulty. Further, do not be deterred by student complaints that “I have read this before.” Having read a story before is immaterial as far as this course is concerned. It’s not the reading of a myth, short story or one-act play per se that is important; rather, it is what we do with each of these that creates the challenge. In some ways this curriculum can be said to resemble a game of chess. In a chess match, the rules are understood by both players, and the roles of the pieces are clearly defined…and yet each game played (or story written) turns out to be a unique and surprising variation upon those structural commonalities. The variability and unpredictability of chess—worked out within the same, consistent set of rules and procedures—is immensely engaging. Why shouldn't and adventure of reading and thinking about literature be as engaging for students as this figurative chess match? Each of the texts in this course provides new and surprising variations upon the core themes that have been essential to story telling ever since Gilgamesh. A brief list of these themes would include: •The Reconciliation of Individual and Societal Goals and Values •The Impact of Technology and Economies of Scale •The Wish for Renewal: Egyptian, Greek, Roman and Western •The Heroic Quest •The Romantic Revolt Against Progress •Citizenship and the Modern World This program fuses together a two-year humanities curriculum. My advice is to pursue this program for a full year at minimum. For teachers who are adept at creating discussions, and who can augment our first-year selections with their own personalized material, this initial course can easily move to two full and challenging years of work for students—or more. The website states that this program can become the “template” for all future courses in the literature area in your school. I have done this myself, so it is no empty claim. At Bellevue International School I started this program with 7th graders and carried it all the way forward to 12th grade—a total of six years. How did I get six years out of nineteen texts, you might ask. I didn’t. The nineteen texts arranged here would be utilized in the first year (again, regardless of the grade level at which one starts), but the concepts and questions introduced here become the organizing principle for all future literature courses as students move forward. These nineteen short works provide the keys to the next “sixty” canonical works that might be attempted. As keys, these nineteen create an interpretive structure for all that you might choose to do hereafter—whether the teacher uses British, American or World literature anthologies. This program comes with a year-long e mail support opportunity for you. I encourage you to write me at any time to pose a question or to probe a meaning. The one year free email support and consultation commences with your first communication; not with the date of your purchase. Topschools Humanities Curriculum 1 & 2 Thematic/Literary Goals: To help students acquire a framework for the reading and thinking about literature; •To enable students to identify structural elements (plot, theme, setting) and language use: symbolism, irony, connotation, denotation et al. •To enable students to see that fundamental story patterns and themes span and link together cultures and epochs; •To enable students to appreciate the metaphor behind all story-telling; Reading Assessment Targets
•State both literal or inferred main ideas and provide text based support
• Use graphic organizers to analyze and compare themes and main ideas in two or more texts
• Develop questions before, during, and after reading
• Compare/contrast recurring themes; similarities and differences
• Examine how an action leads to long-lasting effects
• Judge the effectiveness of the author’s use of literary devices and language
• Draw conclusions about style, tone, mood based upon language choice
• Identify the persuasive effects of vocabulary
• Compare the development of an idea or concept in two or more texts
Writing Assessment Targets • Special emphasis on short (3-8 sentence) one paragraph in-class timed responses to specific prompts
•Formulate a precise topic that responds to the prompt and that takes a position that will be the controlling idea of the paragraph
•Provide supporting evidence from text by weaving exact quotes into expository sentences within the paragraph
•Use standard devices or paragraph hooks for making transitions between two or more paragraphs
vSee Topschools Writing Curriculum for specific instruction on voice, fluency, word choice, sentence construction, phrase and clause variation, and creative deployment of parts of speech within sentences. Excerpts from the text commentaries I have written for this Course
|
|
"...Virtually every story that has ever been written features this pattern; and with the emergence of written language that accompanied the birth of civilization, such story-telling continues the tradition of sympathetic magic." "...Orpheus comes very close to achieving his goal. But he must fail for the very same reason that Isis cannot immortalize the son of the King of Syria, and for the very same reason that Osiris must fit--and must want to fit--into Set's coffin." "...Stories that feature this pattern not only replicate seasonal cycles, but also re-tell the story of the long and difficult journey undertaken when our ancestors made the transition from hunting and gathering to agriculture." "...It is clear that Daedalus contravenes deep laws, but he does so out of necessity..." "...Highway 77 is not an Eden. The Dionysiac wildness of the place suggests something other than Ovid's Golden Age. Certainly, Highway 77 represents the world before civilization; or the world we shall return to when nature reasserts domination over the 'city of man': a time when 'roots will have cleft the rocks and made them crumble.' Further, its denizens--not unlike the wild hunters in Golding's Lord of the Flies-- behave recklessly." "...Yet, if we were to overlay the Greek myth onto the Egyptian, we could ask: If the Poughkeepsie is the River Styx, and if the 'Polacks' are the composite Charon, then do they row Kip to the land of Death, or from Death to Life? From which shore have they embarked, and upon what shore shall they land?" "...Osiris floats down the River Nile in a coffin; and Kip floats down the Poughkeepsie in a racing shell. Kip has been figuratively slain--for to act as coxswain for the new crew puts Kip in a socially 'dangerous' situation. In this story, the role of the Egyptian god of dessication, Set, would be played by the dread hand of tradition, and by the ethical dilemma posed by Kip's own ambivalence. Mary, his girlfriend, plays the role of Isis—for while Kip's social life in the Ivy League rowing world will probably not be resurrected after his crew's embarrassing defeat, her powerful presence guides Kip, and guarantees that he shall be 'resurrected.'" "...If Updike's A&P is a symbol for the Garden of Eden, then Lengel must be its Jehovah. Explore with students the parallels that we have been pursuing ever since Level 1. Certainly the 'apple' and the 'temptation' are present here--though we may be invited to consider fancy herring snacks as the new forbidden fruit. An interesting question to pose: do the girls play the role of Eve to Sammy's Adam; or are they the serpent or sirens who lure Sammy to a shipwreck in the parking lot? Remember that while Icarus crashes into the sea, Sammy executes his adolescent swan dive through the electric eye door." "...We are led, therefore, to question the 'beach.' While it seems to be a paradise of independence and freedom, it may actually represent the world of obligation that all adults must enter. Ulysses and the sirens again. Adam and Eve leave the Garden in order to till the fields and bring forth children in pain; Sammy leaves the store (expulsion) to enter a harsh and indifferent world (heat waves rising up off of car hoods, crying children). As he looks back through the window (remember that Orpheus looked back at Eurydice and lost everything) he discovers the true cost of his gesture. What is more, the girls (like Eurydice) have vanished. At the conclusion of the story, Sammy is doomed to wander the parking lot maze in search of the actual memory--or of the mirage." "...Regarding the Ovidian myth of history, Ayn Rand positions herself both as a futurist and a capitalist--and declares war upon collectivist/romantic notions that would return the world to a state of primitive simplicity and love. The world of the Brotherhood seems to be devoted to the Golden Age in that it attempts to suppress the dangers of Ovid's 'Iron Age.' But oddly--and this is central to Ayn Rand's thesis--the means that it employs to return humanity to paradise requires an increase in governmental power, rather than a decrease. This contradiction inverts Ovid's myth of history. And necessarily so, Ayn Rand might add. The myth of the Golden Age is just that: a myth...and its false promises could only be achieved by a resort to fascism or communism. Here, she takes on Plato's Republic and the Lycurgan constitution--and would be in full sympathy with the ideals that Pericles enunciates in his Funeral Oration--the full text of which is reprinted below." "...But we feel even more sharply that Bradbury's world is a world of limits. The ramp is not to be left; one visits, almost without visiting, the past. What is important—and what must be preserved intact—is the present: the here and now of immediate reality in real time. The "escape" is full of risk, furtive and constraining. In a sense, the journey to the past is a step into the coffin of Osiris: a time machine that whirls those who are lost to the world back through the currents of the river of time. Canute has returned triumphant, and someone must pay for this Pyrrhic victory. "...How astonishing Bradbury's mix is: we return to Eden; but the act of returning to Eden is a 'temptation' and 'fall' that causes an incredible 'expulsion' (rhymes with explosion!). Dorothy Simple's Primanproper seems rather attractive, when compared to the 'wild roses' of the Jurassic. |
Site Licenses Authorizing Use by All Teachers in the School: Topschools Humanities Multiple Teacher/Site License w/ 1 year email support: $389
|
|
© 1998, 2007